Windows Phone 7 on Nokia: We Don't Think So!
By Phil Barker on December 20,
 2010 at 00:00,

It's a rumour that won't disappear, and one that crops up at least once every couple of months. The idea of Nokia buying into Windows Phone 7 popped up again when ex-Microsoft  man Stephen Elop took the helm at Nokia a few months back, and now it's doing the rounds again. We still think it's a crazy idea, however. Join us after the break to find out why...

With ex-Microsoft man Stephen Elop now in charge of Nokia, it seems the internet can't produce enough rumours about Nokia and Windows Phone 7. Leading the current crop of rumours is Eldar Murtazin – a chap known for stories that have to be taken with a pinch, or bucket full, of salt.

According to ZDNet, Murtazin's newletter states that Nokia is currently in talks with Microsoft about including Windows Phone 7 on future devices.

In this case, we agree with ZDNet, which goes on to say:

“Nokia is working hard on future versions of Symbian and their MeeGo OS with Intel so I highly doubt they are going to throw in the towel and adopt a Microsoft OS that is in its infancy and has a long way to go.”

One of the biggest reasons we can't see the inclusion of Windows Phone 7 happening on a Nokia handset in the near future is Qt. Nokia has spent a lot of money on its development platform, and Qt makes it easier than ever to create games and apps for its own operating systems.

Qt also makes it incredibly easy to port games and apps between Symbian and MeeGo – thereby supporting all of Nokia's handsets. Windows Phone 7 is a completely different platform, so Nokia would effectively have to start again with the Ovi Store – a service that's growing on a huge basis every day.

There's also the small matter of existing customers. Nokia currently has the largest customer base, with hundreds of millions of Nokia users around the world, and not all of these users are tech savy. By sticking with Symbian – with MeeGo available for more adventurous users – current owners are guaranteed a similar user experience.

It means owners of Nokia feature phones will be able to upgrade to devices like the Nokia N8, without feeling lost or not being able to navigate the OS. With Windows Phone 7 in place, users would have to get used to an entirely new experience.

It seems that ZDNet agrees, stating: “Those who use Nokia devices generally like the familiarity and functionality of Symbian so a device running WP7 may turn them off”.

Via ZDNet

  • Olivier

    Typical US nonsense. These rumours will die when the 1Q2011 Symbian sales figures will be published, lol !

  • andy burgin

    Nokia ought to keep there own Symbian software running instead of joining the same software with the others,or just do a deal with microsoft to help them make symbian more advance,as thats were Nokia loses out with rest as Apple an Samsung produce software for pcs or laptops

  • Mark

    The author is missing the point. Nokia would be producing devices for MS just like HTC does. Nokia could and would still produce Symbian and Meego devices and would be most unlikely to irritate their existing satisfied user base by discontuinuing Symbian. They could, however, reach new customers who might not otherwise buy Nokia because they think of Symbian as too difficult to learn. Witness the example of the Iphone fanatics. The battle cry is “It’s so EASY!”

    Symbian lovers take warning. We Palm users have yet to find a newer OS that meets our needs as well as our late, lamented Palm OS but Palm is dead anyway.

  • Steve

    @andy burgin
    At it’s core Symbian is already more advanced than iOS, Android or WP7, I doubt M$ will have much to offer in that regard.

    Only when Symbian gets a dumbed down Fisher-Price like interface similar to iOS (which LG believed was copied from the Prada) will Joe Shmo start noticing how excellent it’s performance is.

  • James

    This rumor was started by Eldar Murtazin from Russia. It is not “typical US nonsense” .

  • dpr

    I think Nokia should stick to Symbian and MeeGo. It should enhance the user experience thru QT. Going to windows or android will make it like rest others. There wont be any differentiation.

  • 0batman

    Whatever Os nokia decides to deploy, it better make up its mind fast. When i buy a nokia smartphone, i want a guarntee that it will be capable of upgrading to every new version of nokia’s os for years to come. Just like in ios.
    I have decided not to buy the n8 because Nokia is not coming out and saying what exactly will be the status of its os, say 2 years later.
    People wont sit on the fence long. They will buy ios and get invested there forever.

  • Olivier

    @James: every week it’s the same story in the US media: Symbian is dead, Nokia will adopt Android, Windows, etc. Such stupidity makes me sick …

  • iqbal

    I think the image of nokia is symbian+meego and the image of symbian+meego is nokia. Please don’t ruin it. Be unique. I love nokia :)

  • Jason

    Haha, this article should stay on the internet forever.

  • Uber-andy

    This is one funny article, it’s only been a couple of months and look where we are.

    @Olivier, I’m guessing you’re going to backtrack on those comments seeing how Android smashed Symbian in that quarter. I’m actually from the UK and the funny thing is the British media have not mentioned how Blackberry devices outsold Android. iOS and symbian devices in the UK, nobody saw that coming